You are viewing 1 of your 1 free articles
Jules Birch gives his take on Theresa May’s speech to Housing 2019 yesterday
You wait more than 100 years for a prime minister to address your conference and you get one with less than a month left in the job.
It’s tempting to dismiss Wednesday’s speech by Theresa May to the Chartered Institute of Housing (CIH) conference on the basis that it was made by a lame-duck leader whose decisions could all be overturned by her successor on 24 July.
Even the sight of a premier hot-footing it straight from Prime Minister’s Questions in London to the conference in Manchester can be seen less as a reflection of housing’s importance than of how much time she has on her hands during the Tory leadership contest.
As she said herself, even the venue was a reminder of one of her worst moments: the disastrous leader’s speech in the same hall at the Conservative Party conference in 2017 that ended with her losing her voice and the set falling apart around her.
“Her speech came complete with an appreciation of a Tory housing history that has not always been about the relentless hostility to social and council housing of Mrs Thatcher and Mr Cameron”
Yet that same conference saw her dedicate her premiership to fixing housing and it was part of a journey since the Grenfell Tower fire that has seen Ms May’s government move away from the policies of David Cameron, George Osborne and Policy Exchange and re-embrace the ‘our first social service’ traditions of Churchill and Macmillan.
Like her speech to the National Housing Federation conference last September, this one came complete with an appreciation of a Tory housing history that has not always been about the relentless hostility to social and council housing of Ms Thatcher and Mr Cameron.
In this one she mentioned the centenary of the Addison Act and the space standards ushered in by the Tudor Walters Committee and the earlier version of the ‘property-owning democracy’ promoted by Noel Skelton in the 1920s.
Ms May has been a prime minister of contradictions, promising to tackle “burning injustices” in large part created by policies she accepted as a cabinet minister and paying tribute to the Windrush generation who suffered under the “hostile environment” that she created as home secretary.
And try telling the tens of thousands of people living in flats wrapped in dangerous cladding or stuck in temporary accommodation that the results of her housing policies “speak for themselves”.
But, lame duck or not, this was the speech of a Tory leader who really seems to believe in her change of direction.
Beyond the housebuilding numbers and the soundbites about “restoring the dream of homeownership”, I was struck by her claims that “our truly radical reforms, our biggest breaks with the past, have come in work to support those who rent”.
Where that 2017 speech in Manchester had hinted at support for social housing while doubling down on Help to Buy, this one was much more self-confident about leading a government that had moved away from concentrating “solely on boosting homeownership”.
In the private rented sector she was “rebalancing the relationship between tenant and landlord”, referencing the capping of rent deposits and the abolition of letting agent fees, and promising legislation to repeal Section 21 of the 1988 Housing Act.
This is important not just in itself – landlords being able to throw people out “on a whim” who have done nothing wrong is “simply not fair”, she said – but also because it reverses a key part of the most radical Tory legislation of the Thatcher years.
In a similar vein, she hailed u-turns on key parts of Mr Cameron’s agenda for social housing – Pay to Stay, fixed-term tenancies, the forced sale of higher-value council homes, the Housing Revenue Account cap and cuts to housing benefit for supported housing – almost as though they were the policies of a wicked opposition government rather than her own.
“She hailed U-turns on key parts of Mr Cameron’s agenda for social housing almost as though they were the policies of a wicked opposition government rather than her own”
“In recent decades and under successive governments, social housing became another victim of the single-minded drive for homeownership,” she said, arguing that the Social Housing Green Paper had to do more than simply highlight the problem but be “the practical first step in fixing it”.
An action plan and timetable for implementing the green paper reforms is promised in September, including stronger consumer regulation and “a commitment to further boost the supply of high-quality social housing”.
On new homes, too, there was a switch away from laissez-faire Conservatism with a call for national space standards to be mandatory rather than required as a condition of planning permission and then evaded: “Now I am no fan of regulation for the sake of regulation. But I cannot defend a system in which some owners and tenants are forced to accept tiny homes with inadequate storage.
“Where developers feel the need to fill show homes with deceptively small furniture. And where the lack of universal standards encourages a race to the bottom.”
The problem, of course, is that “it will be up to my successor in Downing Street to deal with this” but she said that “the next government should be bold enough to ensure the nationally described space standard applies to all new homes”.
Much the same could be said of a whole range of other housing issues starting with what comes after the green paper. Ms May leaves a legacy of good intentions and unfinished business.
Whether Boris Johnson or Jeremy Hunt – or the new set of ministers they appoint to key positions on housing – will pay any attention to their predecessor very much remains to be seen.
Who could she have possibly had in mind when she argued that “few other areas of public policy better demonstrate the rule that politicians who propose simple answers to complex problems are seldom being entirely honest”?
It certainly seems unlikely that the favourite to succeed will listen to her message that “it is the political world’s focus on the grand gesture rather than incremental change that is partly responsible for the crisis we are dealing with today”.
Jules Birch, award-winning blogger
Watch the speech here:
What’s happening at Housing 2019?
Dispatches from Housing 2019 – Thursday Our round-up of the third and final day
Whatever Theresa May says, social housing is still the victim of a focus on homeownership Editor Martin Hilditch gives Inside Housing’s verdict to the prime minister’s speech
Your Housing 2019 tweets: a selection of tweets from the conference
Theresa May believes in a change of direction – but will Johnson or Hunt pay any attention? Jules Birch gives his take on Theresa May’s speech to Housing 2019
Watch Theresa May’s speech: a video of the prime minister’s speech to Housing 2019 in full
Dispatches from Housing 2019 – Wednesday The key takeaways from day two of the conference and exhibition
John Healey on Grenfell, Boris Johnson and Labour housing policy Ahead of his speech to Housing 2019, the shadow housing secretary takes part in a Q&A with Inside Housing
Dispatches from Housing 2019 – Tuesday Our round-up of all the key talking points in Manchester on the first day of the conference
Housing Heroes 2019 winners announced Find out the 17 winners and 14 commendations at the ceremony on Monday ahead of the conference and exhibition
In full: Terrie Alafat’s opening address to Housing 2019 The full text of the speech given by the chief executive of the Chartered Institute of Housing to open Housing 2019
What will the Hackitt Review changes mean for you? Conference speaker Debbie Larner writes for Inside Housing about building safety
Inside Housing and Aico competition: tell us about your resident safety campaign We launch a new competition to promote fire and carbon monoxide safety
The latest news headlines from the conference:
Next PM will be committed to social housing, says Brokenshire
Homes England strategic partners to get £1bn cash boost
John Healey blasts May's housing record
Don't wait for Hackitt legislation to push ahead with building safety, says MHCLG official
Theresa May: ‘social housing a victim of drive for homeownership’
‘No-deal Brexit an opportunity for housing’, claim sector figures
Banks’ appetite to lend threatens offsite take-up, warns major landlord
Minister: funding allocations should be based on joint-agency working
Sector warned that fire safety costs could eat up HRA cap windfall
Theresa May to give speech at Housing 2019 conference
Regulator ‘found no breaches’ following Dispatches programme on Sanctuary
No funding for removal of combustible balconies, says Malthouse
MHCLG housing supply chief: affordable housing grant increase ‘on the table’ for Spending Review
‘We have got to do the right thing’ on affordable housing, says land director of Homes England
Council boss warns against local authority ‘can’t do’ attitude towards housebuilding
Terrie Alafat says Spending Review must ‘make a real difference’
Sector needs £146bn from government over a decade to end housing crisis, says NHF
Savills housing sector survey: building homes more important than existing stock to housing leaders
Morning Briefing: thousands descend on Manchester for Housing 2019
We are bringing you the most up-to-date, comprehensive coverage of #CIHHousing anywhere, including:
— Inside Housing (@insidehousing)
All the biggest #ukhousing stories
Live tweeting from the key sessions
A daily newsletter rounding up the key talking points
Daily magazines of conference newsWe are bringing you the most up-to-date, comprehensive coverage of #CIHHousing anywhere, including:
— Inside Housing (@insidehousing) June 26, 2019
All the biggest #ukhousing stories
Live tweeting from the key sessions
A daily newsletter rounding up the key talking points
Daily magazines of conference news